Andrea Tells a Story: The WORST Weight Loss Advice I’ve Ever Received


Since beginning my weight loss journey, I’ve received a LOT of unsolicited advice. Like, a lot. Most of it from people far less informed about losing weight than I (now) am, and I am by NO MEANS an expert. I’ve already spent some time telling you how to respond to people like these, but I haven’t shared many of the really bad tidbits of advice I’ve received over the years. By far, the worst bit of advice I’ve received on my journey was, sadly, in my doctor’s office (thankfully not from a doctor).

It was a normal day at my doc’s office, and, as usual, the medical assistant brought me into the exam room and asked me to step on the scale. Now, I don’t know if they do it to be nice or if we as human beings are just really bad a gauging what another person weighs, but they always underestimate my weight, so I give them a number I think it is, and I’m usually within a few pounds. This day was no exception.

The woman commented on how accurate I was, and I told her I weighed every morning after I get out of bed and empty my bladder, but before I eat breakfast.

“Oh no, honey, never weigh yourself first thing in the morning! When you get out of bed in the morning all of the fluids in your body are sticking to your back and the scale won’t read right! You need to weigh yourself right before bed.”


I blinked slowly. I was concerned at receiving medical advice from a medical professional with such an utter lack of knowledge of the laws of physics. Not wanting to argue and extend the pain of a conversation full of scientific ignorance, I nodded and said “Oh, yeah? Thanks, I’ll give it a shot.”

Allow me to drop some SCIENCE on you beautiful people. Weight, as defined by physics, is the force of gravity acting upon an object’s mass (mass is the amount of “matter” in an object). The shape of said object has nothing to do with it. If you have a balloon half filled with water and half with air, it doesn’t matter where in the balloon the water sits, it will weigh the same. The weight will not change if the object changes shape, either, as long as the mass stays the same. So, even IF your body fluids stuck to your back like silly putty after sleeping (we won’t even mention that she insisted the fluids would stick to my back despite me being a stomach sleeper), it wouldn’t change your WEIGHT.

science_believe_neilFeel free to weigh yourself at night, if you so choose. But be aware that you will weigh more than you do first thing in the morning due to fluid retention/food consumption/etc. I weigh myself in the morning on an empty stomach with an empty bladder because it’s the least I’ll weigh all day and the conditions are always the same, so I can get the most accurate readings. As long as you weigh yourself at the same time everyday in pretty much the same clothes you’ll do fine.

tyson-bullshitYes, this blog is full of Neil deGrasse Tyson because he is my science crush. ❀ Neil!

What’s the worst weight loss advice you’ve ever received?


9 thoughts on “Andrea Tells a Story: The WORST Weight Loss Advice I’ve Ever Received”

  1. No bad advice to mention here, but I do have a couple comments.

    First, whenever someone gives you the “water sticking to your back theory”. Your answer should be this– Better to have it stick to my back, because I hate it when it sticks to my ass.

    Next, and this has to deal with the balloon. If you hold the balloon upside down, all the water will be sitting in the top of the balloon. If the water is in the top, then it must be lighter than air. If it is lighter than air, then obviously it lost weight. So, if you hold upside down water balloons while you weight in, then you will weigh less. EVEN IN THE MORNING. πŸ™‚ πŸ™‚

    Konrad from Sparkpeople.


    1. I love that! Now I just need to keep my stash of magic water balloons handy to lose those last pesky 10 lbs! πŸ˜‰ Thanks so much for your comment! (And it would be okay if a little of it stuck to my ass lol)


  2. This blog made me laugh right out loud…seriously. The worst advice I ever got was from a friend of a family member. She told me to eat nothing but oatmeal until I lost all the weight I wanted. I was 15 and even at that point in my life I knew the lady was nutso! πŸ™‚

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Revision. I said the grain post was my favorite post so far. Now this one is. Where in Sam Heel did she get that
    idea of fat sticking to one’s back?! That’s absolutely crazy. Maybe she should get out of the doctor’s office and just
    run for President of the U.S. Like Nichol, I laughed out loud. (Always a great way to start the day.) Keep up this blog.
    Because we need more sane and intelligent advice. And advice like hers is scary, really scary.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Stuck to your Back??? WTH, gaaaawww……lol! Hilarious. Someone told me, on SP, for gawd’s sakes, that the only true way to lose weight is to drink water with pears and mint, cuz, SCIENCE! Like, all day long and nothing else, no DUH! ANYONE who drinks water ONLY all day will lose weight, umkay? Love your stuff, Andrea!

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: