When the Scale Lies: The Importance of Progress Shots

Scale-liesWhen someone decides to lose weight, often times the focus is on the number on the scale. At 275 lbs, I was morbidly obese, and shedding pounds was the most important thing to me. I was pre-hypertensive and pre-diabetic, and the scale was my main tool for determining success. Weight loss isn’t linear, and I was aware of this, but the trend was downward oriented, so I was happy. But when I reached my goal weight of 160 lbs in August 2014, things changed: I switched to maintenance mode, upped my calories, and started strength training. And that’s when the panic began.

With eating slightly more (I didn’t go crazy, just a couple hundred calories) and adding kettlebells to my workout routine, the scale started to climb. And climb. And climb. November through January I was in a pretty dark place. I almost got back to 175, a gain of 15 lbs from my goal. Despite insistence that I was looking fantastic, despite my size 10 jeans being downright baggy, despite needing a belt, despite upping my kettlebell from 20 lbs to 30 lbs to do the same exercises, I was distressed. I looked at my 100 lbs down photos from the year before and didn’t see any changes from what I saw in the mirror. What was I doing wrong?

Comparison photos early on in my weight loss journey.
Comparison photos early on in my weight loss journey. A 12-lb difference. And yes, it’s a little scary sharing these. But you know what? I TRUST YOU.

I cut my calories back from 2100 to 1900 per day. I (sort of) tried to add in some extra cardio. Okay, I’m just trying to move a little bit more. The scale started moving back in the right direction, slowly, so slowly, but moving. But the other day I took some photos of myself while I was working out, and I saw it. I saw the strength in my arms and the lines on my belly that WERE NOT stretch marks but the shadows of muscles, there, deep under the skin. Later that day I grabbed one of the old 100 lb down photos and, using Gimp, stuck the old photo right next to the new.

Until I put these photos side-by-side, I thought I was screwing something up. Seriously.
Until I put these photos side-by-side, I thought I was screwing something up. Seriously.

Do you ever have one of those moments where you realize you’ve been a total fool for not realizing something? For focusing so much on one thing that you can’t see the forest for the trees? This was my moment. Because despite there being less than 6 lbs of difference between the two photos, the visual difference was striking. And I realized that 10 lbs I had gained since goal wasn’t fat. I wasn’t a failure. I was doing something right. It took a shift in perspective, but I got there. And if it wasn’t for those progress photos from my 100 lbs down goal, I wouldn’t have anything to compare it to.

Think about it: you look at yourself every day. It’s hard to notice changes when you’re looking every day, because changes are small. How many of us started our weight loss journeys because of seeing a picture where we couldn’t believe how big we’d gotten? We use those photos as a motivational tool to get the ball rolling, and we should continue to use those on our journeys. This, I’ve realized, is EXTRA important AFTER we reach goal. Because while the scale can be a very useful tool, it sometimes lies.


Also? Don’t be afraid to show these pictures to other people. I mean, not just any stranger on the internet, but people you trust. I posted the last set of photos on a weight loss group on Facebook. These people are mostly strangers to me, but they’re part of a group that shares a fandom, so I figured it was a safe place, and it was. I was almost brought to tears, though, when a woman commented on the photo with the simple phrase: “Nice abs!” Who? ME?! I realized for the first time in my life, MY ENTIRE LIFE, I was FIT. Not skinny, not thin, but FIT. And that, my friends, is a wonderful feeling.

11 thoughts on “When the Scale Lies: The Importance of Progress Shots”

  1. Awesome reminder! I started up with weights at the gym regularly a few months ago, and it’s been frustrating to see the scale not budge. Fortunately, the belt notches are budging, what I see in the mirror is looking better, and I can *feel* the difference the strength training is making. The number on the scale is just another data point – it’s interesting and it can be useful, but it’s not the goal. I always said that if I only wanted to see a lower number on the scale, I could just chop off a body part and be done with it.

    You are looking so strong! You make me want to try to go for abs. I’m kind of enjoying my mini she-hulk runner’s legs, but visible abs would be nice (hey, vanity can be a good motivator).

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I think there’s as dramatic a difference for you between 175 and 169 as there was between 251 (which you really carried well) and 175. Really remarkable.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. ou look fantastic.
    My strength training has been halted dead in it’s tracks due to injury, so I’m back to cardio only for a while again until I heal up. 😦 (If I can’t bend over to pick up a tube of chapstick off the floor, or hug a cat, kettlebells are out of the question until further notice, as well as anything requiring me to get on the floor, because it’s too hard to get up off of it!).
    So, that 20 lb kettlebell I was considering is on hold indefinitely, since I’m going to have to start from scratch again. Boo.
    In the interim, I’m avoiding the scale out of utter terror of what it might say. Lol.


  4. Man, a STRIKING difference between the two pics and only 6 lbs! Amazing. I had no idea that strength/weight training could do this. Now I’m psyched more than ever to begin AGAIN and add weights/kettles! Thank you, honey! Amazing post.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: